Their mother maintains the October shooting was accidental, while a judge found probable cause for a second-degree murder charge.
WASHINGTON — A 16-year-old boy has been charged as an adult with second-degree murder while armed in the fatal shooting of his twin brother inside their Northeast Washington home, though their mother has repeatedly said the shooting was an accident.
Jamari Young was arrested Nov. 18 in connection with the Oct. 25 death of his twin brother, Jabrell Young, also 16, according to the Metropolitan Police Department. Police said members of the Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task Force located and arrested Jamari under a D.C. Superior Court warrant. He appeared in court the next day and was ordered held without bond, according to news reports.
Police responded at about 8:36 a.m. Oct. 25 to a home in the 200 block of 46th Street Northeast after a report of a shooting. Officers found Jabrell unconscious and not breathing with an apparent gunshot wound. D.C. Fire and EMS personnel attempted lifesaving measures, but Jabrell was pronounced dead at the scene. Police described the case as domestic in nature.
According to an affidavit obtained by People, the brothers had been arguing and wrestling after one of them was heard objecting to the other touching his belongings. Their mother, Chantel Poe, told investigators she tried to separate the twins. She said a firearm then discharged while it was in Jamari’s hand, according to the affidavit.
The affidavit also says Jamari immediately indicated that he had not intended for the gun to discharge and apologized after the shooting. Poe told investigators that her sons were extremely close and said she believed the shooting was accidental. She has continued to make that argument publicly since her surviving son was taken into custody.
At Jamari’s first court appearance, a judge found probable cause to allow the second-degree murder case to move forward, according to People and other reports citing the hearing. The judge reportedly said the evidence did not necessarily show that Jamari intended to kill his brother. A probable-cause finding is not a determination of guilt, and the charge against Jamari remains an allegation.
The Metropolitan Police Department said Jamari is being prosecuted as an adult under Title 16 of District of Columbia law. Police have not publicly provided a detailed account explaining where he was during the weeks between the shooting and his arrest. Reports also differ slightly in describing how he came into custody, with police saying a fugitive task force located and arrested him while relatives have said the family arranged for him to surrender.
Poe has rejected suggestions that her surviving son deliberately killed his brother and has said the family is grieving Jabrell while also supporting Jamari through the criminal case. Authorities have not announced a final determination about whether the shooting was intentional or accidental. That question is expected to remain central as prosecutors and the defense present evidence in court.
Jamari remained held without bond after his initial court appearance. It was not immediately clear from the reports reviewed whether he had entered a plea. The case remains pending in D.C. Superior Court, where prosecutors will have to prove the criminal charge beyond a reasonable doubt if the case proceeds to trial.