Drew Garnier, a 33-year-old New York man, admitted to the murder of his pregnant wife, Samantha Garnier, 29, and the assault of their two young daughters. The tragic incident occurred on September 4, 2024, when Samantha was five months pregnant with the couple’s third daughter. The father of the victim, in his victim impact statement, suggested that the motive behind the crime was the defendant’s disappointment over the unborn child’s gender.
The New York State Police were called to the Garnier residence in Masonville, New York, following a domestic dispute report. Upon their arrival, Drew Garnier surrendered and was treated for minor injuries. Samantha Garnier, however, was airlifted to a nearby hospital, where she was later pronounced dead. The couple’s daughters, aged 6 and 9, were also treated for stab wounds but eventually recovered.
During Drew Garnier’s sentencing hearing, Samantha’s father read his victim impact statement. He expressed his belief that Drew Garnier’s anger over the unborn child’s gender led to the murder. He told the court, “He had wanted a boy.” He also spoke about the trauma the couple’s daughters experienced due to the horrific crime against their mother, stating, “I am their father now. I will protect them.”
Drew Garnier, who also pleaded guilty to two assault charges for stabbing his daughters, requested permission to contact them while serving his sentence. Delaware County District Attorney Shawn Smith objected to this request, asking for no-contact orders for as long as legally possible. Judge John Hubbard agreed with the District Attorney but noted that the girls could choose to contact their father if they wished.
Judge Hubbard issued stay-away orders for both girls until 2056. Despite this, Drew Garnier reportedly refused to sign them. The judge admonished Garnier, stating, “You took a life and injured your children. They had a right to expect protection from you.” As per his plea agreement, Drew Garnier was sentenced to 30 years in prison, followed by 15 years of probation upon release.