Breaking News Just In from The Daily Horn
The Daily Horn
Featured on [System.DateTime]
Worker Guns Down Co-Worker’s Wife

A judge sentenced Ernest Cunningham to 42 years in prison after prosecutors said he went to a southeast Denver apartment to confront a former co-worker and instead fatally shot 23-year-old Kelsey Roberts-Gariety when she answered the door.

The sentence closes the trial phase of a case that drew unusual attention because investigators said the motive came from a workplace dispute, not a domestic conflict or a random attack. A Denver jury convicted Cunningham of second-degree murder on Dec. 22, 2025, and the district attorney’s office announced the sentence on March 3 after the Feb. 27 hearing. For Roberts-Gariety’s family, the ruling brought a clear legal result, but not an end to the grief or to the questions that followed the killing.

Police and prosecutors say the case began with anger that followed Cunningham from work to the couple’s home. On June 29, 2024, officers responded to a report of a shot fired at an apartment building near South Dexter Street and East Kentucky Avenue in southeast Denver. When they arrived, they found Roberts-Gariety dead from a gunshot wound. A resident told investigators they heard a gunshot and the sound of someone running away. Another neighbor recorded a man leaving in a car. Jack Gariety, Roberts-Gariety’s husband, arrived later and told police Cunningham “knew where they lived and had issues with him,” according to court records described in local reporting. Those early witness accounts gave detectives a fast outline of what had happened at the door and pointed them toward a suspect almost as soon as the homicide scene was secured.

Public summaries of the arrest affidavit say the dispute had been building before the shooting. Gariety told police Cunningham had worked with him and had been fired after using drugs on the job. After that, the affidavit said, Cunningham became angry, repeatedly called Gariety to threaten him and had shown up at the apartment before without being invited. Prosecutors later used that sequence to argue that Cunningham did not arrive by mistake and did not fire in confusion after some sudden argument with Roberts-Gariety. They said he came to confront Gariety while armed, but Roberts-Gariety reached the front door first. The public record reviewed this week does not include a detailed statement from Cunningham explaining his thinking. That leaves one question open even after conviction: what he expected to happen once he reached the building. What jurors settled in December was narrower and still decisive. They found the shooting met the standard for second-degree murder, rejecting any suggestion that it was accidental or legally justified.

Roberts-Gariety’s age and the setting of her death kept the case in public view long after the shooting. She was 23, had moved to Denver with her husband and remained closely tied to relatives in Ohio. Her obituary says she was born May 14, 2001, and lived in Denver with Jack Gariety and their pets. Her sister Kayla Ratliff told local television that “anybody who met her loved her.” Another sister, Kylie Al-Nubu’at, remembered the moment the family learned she had been killed and said the news felt impossible to accept. Those details shaped the public understanding of the case because the conflict that brought Cunningham to the apartment did not grow out of Roberts-Gariety’s own relationship with him. Investigators said she was pulled into violence aimed at someone else. That made the crime feel especially abrupt and senseless to relatives and to neighbors in the building, where an ordinary day at home became a homicide investigation in seconds.

The case drew even more scrutiny because Cunningham was on parole when the shooting happened. Local reporting said he had previously served time on a 20-year burglary sentence. Months after the killing, 9NEWS reported that a parole officer had labeled Cunningham low risk about two months before Roberts-Gariety was killed, even though his file showed two failed drug tests and two missed tests in the prior four months. The Colorado Department of Corrections later acknowledged major problems in some parole risk assessments and said it would review more than 1,700 cases. Those reviews were separate from the murder prosecution, and they did not change the evidence presented about what happened at the apartment door. But they widened the public stakes around the case. For Roberts-Gariety’s family, the issue was no longer only what Cunningham did on June 29. It was also how a man later convicted in a deadly shooting had been moving through the parole system without a risk label that matched the danger the case now appears to show.

The court process moved far more slowly than the shooting itself. Cunningham was charged after the June 2024 killing, and the case remained in the criminal system for about 18 months before a Denver jury returned its guilty verdict on Dec. 22, 2025. Sentencing followed on Feb. 27, and the district attorney’s office announced the result publicly on March 3. District Attorney John Walsh said Roberts-Gariety “would be with us today were it not for Ernest Cunningham” and said the sentence made sure he would pay “a heavy price” for what he did. The office said Senior Deputy District Attorney Matt James and Associate Deputy District Attorney Makayla Samour led the prosecution, with Denver Police Detective Gavin Whitman also credited in the case. The 42-year prison term effectively ends the trial phase. As of this week, the public reports reviewed for this story did not describe a new hearing date or a new filing that would quickly return the case to open court.

For Roberts-Gariety’s family, the sentence brought some relief without changing the daily fact of her absence. Al-Nubu’at told 9NEWS she viewed any sentence longer than 20 years as “basically a life sentence” for Cunningham because of his age. Then she turned to what her family still carries, saying, “We’re serving a life sentence of grief, so now I feel like justice has been served.” Ratliff said relatives planned to keep speaking her sister’s name and wanted to honor her love of animals, including through support for rescue work. Those remarks help explain why the case lingered in Denver and in Roberts-Gariety’s Ohio hometown long after the crime scene was cleared. The official record now shows a conviction, a prison term and a completed sentencing hearing. The people closest to Roberts-Gariety still describe something harder to capture in court language: a young woman answering her own door, a gunshot, a rush of footsteps and a family forced to rebuild around a loss the criminal system could punish but never undo.

As of March 7, Cunningham was headed into the Colorado prison system under a 42-year sentence. Unless a post-sentencing motion or appeal surfaces later, no new hearing date had been publicly described, and the case stood at the end of its trial phase.

Author note: Last updated March 7, 2026.

That's not all:
 
 
 

Recent headline:

New Mother Killed, Husband Dead in Hospital Shooting

A 24-year-old woman who had just given birth was shot and killed Sunday night inside Baptist Health Brookwood Hospital, and her 19-year-old husband died at the scene from a self-inflicted gunshot wound, police said.

The shooting in the hospital’s Women’s Medical Center has raised fresh questions about security inside medical facilities and the dangers of domestic violence that can spill into public places. Homewood police and the Jefferson County Coroner’s Office have called the deaths an apparent domestic assault and murder-suicide. Hospital officials said they locked down the building as officers secured the scene, then reopened normal operations the next day while investigators continued to gather evidence.

Homewood police said officers were dispatched about 9:25 p.m. Sunday, March 1, after a report of shots fired at the Women’s Center on Medical Center Drive. When officers arrived, they found a man and a woman dead from gunshot wounds, authorities said. The woman, Precious Elicia J’anae Johnson of Birmingham, was a patient at the hospital and had been shot multiple times, the coroner’s office said. The man, Kynath William Terry Jr. of Midfield, died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound, according to the coroner’s report. Family members later confirmed that Johnson and Terry were married and had just welcomed their first child. Police said no one else was injured, and authorities did not say whether the baby was in the room when the shooting happened.

Investigators have not described a motive, and police have released few details about how the gun entered the hospital or where the couple had been immediately before the shots were fired. Homewood police said their preliminary investigation indicates an apparent murder-suicide. The coroner’s office described the case as a domestic assault. In a statement issued Sunday night, the hospital said it went on lockdown “out of an abundance of caution” and added that there was “no active threat to patients, team members or the public.” The statement said the hospital was cooperating with law enforcement. By Monday morning, hospital officials told local media that the lockdown had ended and the hospital was operating as normal.

The incident drew immediate attention in a region where hospitals, like many public places, often balance open access with security concerns. Danne Howard, president of the Alabama Hospital Association, said the shooting was the first event of its kind she had seen in decades of work with hospitals across the state. “In my 30 years of working at the hospital association and representing our hospitals in the state, this is the first time something has occurred like this,” Howard said in an interview with WVTM-TV. Howard said hospitals typically conduct an after-action review after a major incident to identify what worked, what failed and what needs to be changed. She said the hospital association often helps facilities share lessons learned and best practices. Howard also said Alabama does not have statewide security mandates for hospitals, though she added that policymakers could revisit that after this case.

The shooting also renewed discussion about domestic violence during pregnancy and shortly after childbirth. Rebecca McWilliams, executive director of One Place Metro Alabama Family Justice Center, said her first reaction when she heard about the deaths was that the violence sounded domestic. “It truly affects all of us. And it is a true threat to public health and public safety,” McWilliams said in a WBRC-TV interview. McWilliams said national data show homicide remains a major cause of death for pregnant and postpartum women, and she said the risk can rise when relationships are already unstable. Birmingham police have reported an uptick in domestic violence calls in recent weeks, McWilliams said, though she and police officials did not immediately provide specific figures tied to that increase.

While shootings inside hospitals remain rare, the Birmingham area has seen other incidents over the past decade that led to lockdowns and large police responses. In 2012, a gunman opened fire at St. Vincent’s Hospital in Birmingham and wounded a Birmingham police officer and two hospital employees before officers shot and killed the suspect, according to published reports from the time. In 2018, a shooting at UAB Highlands Hospital killed a hospital employee and injured another worker, and the suspect later died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound, authorities said. Those cases, like the Brookwood shooting, prompted shelter-in-place orders and later reviews of how hospitals control access to sensitive units such as labor and delivery.

Police have described the Brookwood case as an active investigation even though the suspect is dead. Investigators typically complete interviews, review surveillance video, collect and test the firearm, and document the scene for a final case file. The coroner’s office can also play a role by confirming causes and manners of death through autopsies and medical records. Hospital leaders can conduct their own internal review focused on safety procedures, staffing and access control, separate from the criminal investigation. Howard said after-action reports often lead to practical changes, such as new screening points, updated visitor rules, or tighter controls at unit entrances, depending on how the suspect gained access and where security layers failed.

City leaders and family members have also begun to grapple with the loss. Homewood Mayor Jennifer Andress said officers “acted quickly to secure the scene and ensure there was no ongoing threat to the public,” and she said the city was working with hospital leadership as the investigation moves forward. Terry’s mother told WVTM-TV she could not understand why the shooting happened and said she never expected her son to become violent, even though she knew the couple had been dealing with marital problems. Police have not said whether there were prior calls for service involving the couple or whether any court records played a role in the investigation.

As of Tuesday, police had not released additional details about the moments leading up to the shooting or the condition and location of the newborn at the time. Homewood police have said they will provide updates through their public information officer as investigators finish the case file. Hospital operations continued normally after the lockdown was lifted, and the Alabama Hospital Association said it expects hospitals statewide to share lessons from Brookwood’s after-action review once it is completed.

Contact Us:
TheDailyHorn.com
137 E Elliot #1553
Gilbert AZ
85299-1553

Inquiries: contact@thedailyhorn.com

Visit The Daily Horn

Intended for: [Contact.Email] sent on [System.DateTime]

View Online  | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy Unsubscribe from All